This eyeliner came in a back of three other liners. I was thinking it was going to be a navy blue color, but it just looks black to me. This liner stays on very well and it applies easy too. The one thing that I noticed though is that the applicator is a lot longer in the new liquid liners than the old ones. This makes it a little harder to apply, but it is still pretty easy. So, I'd say if you are looking for a navy liner like I was, I wouldn't buy this one in midnight. Just because it looks exactly like black!
Product: e.l.f. Liquid Liner in "Midnight"
Bottom Line: Leave It! (Because it looks like black)